*
Getty photos https://images.daznservices.com/di/library/sporting_news/92/a0/serena-williams-012817-getty-ftr_stbpakdklzdc1x5qm4t12ove7.jpg?t=-411958743&w=500&quality=80

Into my third decade as Sporting News college basketball columnist, there have been times as soon as I’ve agreed to radio interviews and then been placed in place to deal with questions the honestly did not seem precious answering. But a live transfer is no necessarily the best possible venue for such a stand, and also so i answer.

You are watching: Lulu garcia-navarro john mcenroe


The most persistent of these questions emerged when the good Pat Summitt was alive and also well and coaching the Tennessee Lady Vols. That generally associated some sports of: “How carry out you think she would execute if she were coaching a men’s team?”


The concern itself was an insult to Coach Summitt, and to every one of women’s basketball, and also the an answer I occurred over the years reflected some version of this declaration. We never hear questions about how Mike Krzyzewski would do coaching women, and so we recognize that the not around whether Summit would be able to apply comparable methods and also techniques when coaching a various gender. That the idea that she has actually not to be truly coaching at the highest possible level.

MORE: classic photos that Serena Williams


That to be the trap set for john McEnroe by NPR organize Lulu Garcia-Navarro earlier this week during an interview to encourage his latest book, “But Seriously.” the answered honestly, however less diplomatically 보다 he might have, and thus that still is gift ground v a dispute that is ludicrous however preventable. Probably the conversation has been good for publication sales. That is no my department.

Here is the part of their exchange that became problematic:

Garcia-Navarro: We’re talking around male players, yet there is, the course, exorbitant female players. Stop talk about Serena Williams. You speak she is the ideal female player in the world in the book.

McEnroe: finest female player ever, no question.

Garcia-Navarro: some wouldn’t qualify it. Some would certainly say she is the best player in the world. Why qualified it?

Here’s what McEnroe might have said, maybe what the should have actually said:

What Serena has achieved stands top top its own. She has won 23 significant singles championships. She has actually won every large doubles tournament there is to win. She represented her country at the Olympics on lot of occasions, and excelled there. Ns don’t think it’s productive for women’s tennis, or women’s sporting activities in general, to shot to draw her into some manufactured fight of the sexes discussion. It’s great for the game that Serena is not only an incredibly achieved athlete but also a massive star.

Here is what McEnroe walk say:

“Oh, uh, she’s not … you median the finest player in the world, period? … Well, due to the fact that if she remained in — if she played the men’s circuit, she’d be like 700 in the world. … that doesn’t typical I nothing think Serena is an significant player. Ns do. Yet the reality of what would take place would be, ns think, miscellaneous that possibly it’d it is in a tiny higher, maybe it’d be a tiny lower. And on a offered day, Serena can beat some players.”

If McEnroe had complied with the best course, he would not have actually wound up defending his explanation on "CBS This Morning" and declining to apologize.

Again, this serves to location McEnroe much much more firmly in the general public discourse. If that may not have actually been his intention, it has the ancillary advantage of placing a brighter spotlight on his book.

However, if the interviewer’s will in the original exchange was to make the case for women’s sports, it to be badly misdirected.

MORE: McEnroe insurance claims Donald Trump available to pay him to play Serena

The concern Garcia-Navarro gift to McEnroe implies that somehow he is responsible because that the separate competitive divisions at Wimbledon, the U.S. Open and the French. That is not. The French open up crowned Suzanne Lenglen together its women’s champion in 1925. Wimbledon started a women’s department in 1884, 7 years ~ the very first tournament. This is just how it has remained in tennis because that a an extremely long time.

It took much of the sports people too long to even shot to catch up. Women’s basketball walk not come to be widely easily accessible in American colleges and also high schools until the beforehand 1970s. Return basketball was introduced to the Olympic games in 1936, over there was no a women’s tournament till 40 year later. Women’s soccer did not truly capture fire right here until the world Cup was staged throughout the U.S. In 1999, and also the american won. The remainder of the human being has been progressively working come improve, with several of the top European clubs — an ext than a dozen year after “Bend It prefer Beckham” — putting more into your women’s teams.

See more: 20 Best Manufacturing Jobs In San Bernardino Ca, Manufacturing Jobs Hiring In San Bernardino, Ca

The NCAA is marking the 45th anniversary that the title IX regulation that increased the development of women’s sports in the U.S. The key passage read: “No person in the United says shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded native participation in, be refuse the services of, or be topic to discrimination under any kind of education program or task receiving commonwealth financial assistance.”

We room nowhere close to where we should be, as evidenced by one SB country report ~ above the lack of woman coaches in women"s university soccer: just 14 of the height 50 programs in department I space coached through women. Talking about this dichotomy is going come do an ext for women"s sporting activities than squeezing McEnroe on man vs. Woman. 

Title IX assisted make play Summitt one of the most prominent sports figures in America over the three years prior come the diagnosis of at an early stage onset Alzheimer’s and her fatality last summer. She didn’t need to coach guys to prove she was worthy the the Naismith Memorial Basketball hall of Fame. She required to coach. And also that’s enough.